Don’t Fund Income Tax Stimulus with Corporate Tax Hikes

By Burnet Maybank

 

I was very pleased to read Governor Sanfords recent call for $205 million in income tax reductions. The Governor is to be applauded for his continued devotion to the cause of tax cuts as a significant economic development stimulus.

I was concerned, however, to read the Governor planned to fund the cuts with an increase on cigarette taxes. This tax hike is projected to fund slightly over half of the cost of the income tax cuts. Clearly, last years billion dollar state government surplus, combined with another projected one billion dollar surplus this year, should be enough money to fund virtually any new government program without a tax hike. In spite of the surplus, there are many tax advocates who propose raising the cigarette tax not to provide relief, but to fund a growing government or to discourage smoking. If a combined 2 billion surplus over the past two years isnt enough to quiet talks of tax hikes, the mind reels at how large the surplus would have to be. After all, it was only several years ago when the entire General Fund was $8 billion!

Last summer I wrote an op-ed pointing out that while cigarette taxes in South Carolina may be low compared to the national average, we have quite a few taxes that are among the highest in the nation (including our individual income tax rates.) Indeed, if you just look at sin taxes, our taxes on beer (3rd highest), liquor (8th highest) and wine (10th highest) are among the highest in the nation. Our real property taxes on manufacturers are the absolute highest in the nation. I urged our General Assembly to spend as much time and energy lowering extremely high taxes as they do raising low ones.

One of the comments I got back from that op-ed was that increased cigarette taxes will have the salutary affect of lowering cigarette consumption, particularly among youth smokers. If accurate, this will surely depress cigarette tax revenue even at the higher tax rate. Experience teaches that raising a consumption tax will produce short term gains in tax revenue followed almost invariably by reductions as people change behavior (for example, by purchasing cigarettes tax free over the internet or at military bases.) Indeed, the flight from premium cigarette brands (which pay tax-equivalents under the Master Settlement Agreement) to off brands (which do not) is already so strong that last year the payments which go to make South Carolinas bond payments were endangered.

We need to look no further than the debate last year over property taxes. While researching this issue, I discovered the Michigan experience. Michigan raised cigarette taxes in 1996 to fund property tax relief. Prior to the hike, from 1993 to 1995, tax collections from cigarette sales rose from $244 million to $620 million. After the tax hike, collections had dropped to $525 million by 1998. Michigan is hardly alone.

My research of some months ago indicate some 18 states plus Cook County, Illinois raised cigarette taxes from 2004 through early 2006. In every instance, there was a decline in sales. In a plan very similar to that of Governor Sanford, Pennsylvania raised taxes by 35 cents. The result was a 13 percent decline in sales over the prior 12 months. Overall sales declined from a low of 4 percent to a high of 28 percent. If that was entirely the result of consumers quitting smoking, then certainly that sales decline is a plus from a health standpoint. But from a tax policy standpoint, that decline proves that a higher cigarette tax is an unreliable way to fund income tax cuts. Virtually every state which has raised a consumption tax has gone through the same experience. Proof of this comes from the example of one of the few tax cuts that Senator Ted Kennedy has supported. In the 1980s, the U.S. Congress enacted a luxury tax on yachts (among other items). The result was a short term hike in tax collections, followed by a sharp decline in yacht sales that resulted in a serious recession in the American yacht building industry, which was then located in Maine and Massachusetts. Congress admitted the error in its ways and repealed the tax.

My point is simple. By all means lower the income tax rate just dont tie the fate of permanent income tax relief to a revenue source that is certain to decline. Focus instead on lowering tax rates in instances where South Carolina has the nations highest.

By South Carolina Policy Council

Since 1986 the South Carolina Policy Council Education Foundation has advocated innovative policy ideas that advance the principles of limited government and free enterprise. The Policy Council is the state’s meeting place for business leaders, policymakers, and academics – as well as engaged citizens – who want to see South Carolina become the most free state in the nation. For questions or comments on the articles on this website, please email Research Director Jamie Murguia.

One thought on “Don’t Fund Income Tax Stimulus with Corporate Tax Hikes”
  1. Anabolic steroids are synthetic (manmade) hormones that may enhance the body’s ability
    to make muscle and stop muscle breakdown. Drugs commonly known as
    “steroids” are categorized as corticosteroidsor anabolic (or
    anabolic-androgenic) steroids. Anabolic steroids should be discouraged because of their potentially dangerous opposed effects.

    It can occur as a outcome of steroids could cause your physique to redistribute fats — round your
    face and also around your midsection. Apart From steroids, some athletes use different substances that they
    suppose will make them better athletes. None can take the
    place of a good strength and conditioning program
    and a well-balanced food plan. As Mayo Clinic points
    out, unwanted effects rely upon how high your dose is and the way lengthy you are taking the treatment.
    A short-term and lower-dose course of prednisone might cause delicate side effects, while taking larger doses or for longer durations could
    increase your risk of more troublesome side effects.
    Research on high school athletes shows they’re less prone to misuse anabolic steroids if their family and friends
    disapprove.
    The key to success lies in education, discipline, and a commitment
    to health. Steroids aren’t a magic answer, but when used correctly, they will
    present the sting needed to attain extraordinary outcomes.
    Whether Or Not you’re an athlete, bodybuilder, or fitness
    enthusiast, steroids is normally a valuable addition to your routine, serving to you unlock new ranges of energy, endurance, and confidence.

    Embrace the probabilities, and take your fitness journey to the subsequent stage.
    HGH works by stimulating the manufacturing of insulin-like progress issue
    1 (IGF-1), which promotes muscle growth and restore. This makes it particularly helpful for people recovering from injuries or these trying to push their physical limits.

    Moreover, HGH has anti-aging properties, helping customers keep a youthful appearance and vitality.

    Withdrawal symptoms emerge once steroid use stops, often manifesting as
    severe temper disturbances, fatigue, and a way of loss. Unlike withdrawal from
    opioids or stimulants, steroid withdrawal is
    pushed by hormonal dysregulation. Exogenous steroid use suppresses natural testosterone manufacturing,
    resulting in a interval of hypogonadism after
    cessation.
    The principle that creatine supplementation will increase
    fats mass is a concern amongst exercising people, probably because some expertise a gain in body
    mass from creatine supplementation. However, randomized managed
    trials (one week to 2 years in duration) do not validate this claim.

    Acute creatine supplementation (7 days) had no effect on fats mass in young
    and older adults; however, fat-free mass was elevated [86, 87].

    Moreover, three weeks of creatine supplementation had no impact on body composition in swimmers [88].
    The addition of creatine to high-intensity interval training had no impact
    on body composition in recreationally energetic females [89].
    In addition, the results of creatine supplementation during resistance coaching overreaching
    had no effect on fat mass [70]. Furthermore, in a group of wholesome leisure male bodybuilders, 5 g/day of creatine consumed
    either pre- or post-training had no impact on fats mass [90].

    For any urgent, probably life-threatening problem, like sudden extreme
    chest ache or problem respiratory, call 911. Creatine monohydrate is the most generally used type and the one most studied.

    After being forced to unpack his deception in the documentary, Johnson tearfully
    turns back to his childhood traumas and absent father, crediting his Non Steroid Muscle Builder (Metis.Lti.Cs.Cmu.Edu) use to a scarcity
    of vanity. Around the time he turned 30, he began living
    what he calls an “ancestral way of life,” which incorporates
    core tenets like “sleep,” “eat,” and “transfer,” in addition to an emphasis on cold plunges and household bonding.

    And even higher, there are steps you can take to assist decrease results.
    And as a end result of prednisone might upset your stomach, take it with meals or milk, and do not
    lie down for a few hours after a dose, in accordance with the
    University of Pennsylvania’s OncoLink. Roasted or baked potatoes — not drenched in butter or salt — are wholesome side dishes,
    she says, and old school oatmeal — not the moment packets —
    makes for a great breakfast. “Getting a selection of fruit and vegetables, you get your potassium [and] get fiber,” she says.
    The protein and fiber help satisfy starvation pangs, and the fruit and veggies contain nutrients that help fight irritation and boost the immune system.

    These receptors are the main gateways extreme acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) makes use of to invade your cells.
    So, “closing” these gates may better protect your body from the virus.
    As Soon As the doctors have stabilized you adequate to go residence, they might provide you with a corticosteroid shot to prevent
    one other attack. Like oral steroids, these pictures are quite highly effective and
    pose a excessive risk of similar unwanted effects.

    Though corticosteroids are crucial treatments, they come with a variety
    of potential side effects. Taking corticosteroids
    for an extended time period, even if at a
    low dose, additionally increases your likelihood of experiencing unwanted side effects.
    In small doses for short quantities of time,
    when their use is monitored by a doctor, anabolic steroids have decrease danger of long-term or dangerous unwanted
    effects. Right Here are six potential unwanted facet
    effects of anabolic steroids when they’re taken at high
    doses and absent a clear medical indication. Nevertheless, if
    you are seeking to construct muscle, corticosteroids aren’t the best kind of
    steroid.
    There was no vital distinction in absolute fat mass loss; however, the creatine group lost ~0.5 kg extra fat mass compared to these on placebo.
    Whereas the physiological and performance outcomes of
    anabolic steroids and creatine may be comparable, their mechanisms of motion and authorized categorization aren’t.

    It is illegal to own and administer anabolic steroids without a physician’s prescription.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *